preview

Alofa Figiel

Good Essays

Authors often borrow from one another, sometimes heavily. Though rooted in very different communities, Sia Figiel and Toni Morrison manage to craft similar narratives that explore what it means live in small, often poor communities. For Morrison, this means experimenting to find a voice that is black—drifting through narrators to find a position that might see the entirety of The Bluest Eye. Figiel, on the other hand, chooses to tell her story in Where ‘We’ Once Belonged by exploring a series of disjointed scenes, mostly from the perspective of her implied narrator, Alofa. By comparing the supporting characters from these two novels, we can draw Morrison’s influence out of Figiel’s novel and examine how Figiel utilizes similar archetypes in …show more content…

In each case, the daughter is ruined in the eyes of their society. The women in Malaefou are “constantly whispering about her [Lili]” (10). Pecola is also a victim of shunning after her miscarriage. Morrison’s narrator notes, “We honed our egos on her, padded our characters with her frailty, and yawned in the fantasy of our strength” (203). Morrison defines Pecola as outcast, driving her mad and sending her to wander among the “coke bottles and milkweed” (203). Figiel, on the other hand, takes the archetype in a different direction. As of mid-way in the book, Lili still has much of her agency and, seemingly, her sanity. The scene in the kitchen between Lili, Moa, and Alofa presumably takes place after her confession to the two girls, but Lili is cogent. She has a job and a stable life, if as a social outcast. The difference in each character is stark. Pecola is depicted as simple-minded and ugly. Lili, on the other hand, is whip smart—immediately catching on that Moa and Alofa are looking for ice cream (9)—and attractive. “Lily was Kelly. She had the best haircut . . . breasts (big-big), pretty legs” (6). These characters, in spite of their similar histories, take very different roads. Perhaps Figiel did not like the idea of treating a character quite as harshly as Morrison treats

Get Access