preview

American Slaves Vs Serfs

Decent Essays

Russian serfs, or peasants who were legally bound to remain on their land, had a huge impact on Russia’s economy, politics, and on the world that we know today. “Serfdom became, more than it had ever before been, the basis of the entire social order.” (Blum, 3-12) American slaves, who were legally owned by whomever bought them, were greatly similar to those of serfs and also had a huge impact on the world today. Some people think that slaves and serfs are the same, but on the contrary, they are not the same, due to environmental factors, historical events, economic circumstances, etc… Because slaves and serfs worked the land, and most of Russia and America were primarily agricultural, laborers were essential to the basic order of the country …show more content…

“In Russia the traditional relationship between lord and serf was based on land. It was because he lived on his land that the serf was bound to the lord.” (Lynch) Slaves were viewed as someone’s own property, nothing more whereas serfs were seen as human, but with little freedom. (Bush) Because of this, serfs had more freedom than slaves did, giving them the ability to rent a small patch of land, have better living conditions, work multiple jobs, etc. It also allowed for serfs to become more independent so they can take care of themselves and their family. There was, however, a limitation to what they could do. Serfs were not allowed to marry without permission, sell his own products, or go to the maker without permission. (Melbourne) American slaves were completely dependable on their masters for food, shelter, and other essential needs to survive. (Kolchin) Serfs were able to be moved around from one job to the next if they were told to do so, whereas slaves mainly only had one job for their entire lives.

The reason for the necessity of slavery had differed from the reason of serfdom as well. The reason that slavery was introduced was to have people work on plantations to produce goods for profit.(Valentine, 255-286) Serfdom was introduced to make nobles dependent, and therefore loyal to the …show more content…

In their society and circumstances both slaves and serfs were the bottom of the social class. They were unfairly treated, and punished if they did something wrong. “...he was deprived of all protection against the abuse of seignorial authority, which was exercised without restraint…” (Melbourne) Both also worked long hours and needed to do whatever their owner or master told them to do. If they had children, they automatically became either slaves or serfs. When the factory industry in Russia was introduced and domestic and foreign trade increased, the area and population of Russia also increased, making landowners wanting to have more land, and therefore needing more serfs. (Blum, 3-12) The serfdom population of Russia was over one-third of its total population.

Get Access