preview

Americans Should Not Be Taxed

Better Essays

"The most perennially political issues in the United States is the question of how much Americans should be taxed. Indeed, discounted over taxes was one of the major motivating factors in the revolution that established the United States as an independent nation"("Extending Tax Cuts", 1). Since taxes are one of the biggest topics in politics, there is always going to be two sides of the subject, and Taxes will always strike controversy in our country. The topic of having the rich pay more in tax has a deep history to consider, and there will always be both supporters and critics who continue to debate this topic.
The initial income tax sparked a debate that has raged ever since. "The Government taxed personal income for the first time in 1862, …show more content…

Consequently, everyone who makes a living in the United States is expected to contribute a portion of their salary to the federal government in the form of taxes. That money is used to fund the day-to-day operations of the federal government, as well as social programs such as Medicare, Medicaid and Social Security, the national defense budget, benefits for retired federal employees and veterans, public education, national infrastructure, including the highway system, and many other aspects of American life ("Taxing Millionaires", 1). The United States requires additional monies to fund all these necessities. If it possessed enough revenue to fund all of these programs, and still have money left, the United States would be one of the most advanced countries, and would rise to an unstoppable economy. If insufficient amounts of money are collected from income tax, schools won't receive the revenue needed to provide programs. As a result, schools would be forced to cut spending, leading to decreased interventions and opportunities needed for each learner. One of the …show more content…

Opponents claim that having the rich pay more in tax is class warfare. For example, former speech writer for former President Richard Nixon, Ben Stein, said on CBS's Sunday Morning, "I am not quite sure what my sin is. I worked for almost every dollar I have." He argues that the wealthy are being punished. "But for what? I don't own any slaves. I employ many people full- and part-time and they are all excited with their pay... what did I do wrong?"("Extending Tax Cuts") Ben Stein reports this as class warfare, Since it requires him to pay additional tax for working hard and earning more money. The bottom 40% of all income earners benefit greatly from the income tax code. "In fact, they actually pay negative income tax rates due to refundable credits, such as the Child Tax Credit and the Earned Income Tax Credit wipe out their tax liability and pay out more money to them than they ever paid in. The income tax burden of low-income earners has trended for years"(Dubay). Since low income earners don’t have enough money to spend on their kids, the government gives them money. In some occasions the government gives these families more than they pay in taxes. Those who oppose this say that raising tax rates on the rich damages economic growth, because it reduces the incentives to work, save, invest, and accept economic risk. Raising taxes on the rich hurts workers at all income

Get Access