preview

Argument Analysis

Decent Essays

The keywords include the following: “synthesize,” “at least three of the sources,” and “defends, challenges, or qualifies.” “Synthesize” indicates the kind of essay required. “At least three of the sources” specifies the amount of evidence required in the essay. “Defends, challenges, or qualifies” tells the writer to take a stance on the issue, which is a crucial element of the essay. These words are the most significant keywords because they either give a direct command to the writer or describe how the writer should qualify the essay’s points. The directions ask the writer to defend, challenge, or qualify the claim that video games do not have cultural value and can cause overly aggressive or violent behavior outside of the game. The introduction …show more content…

Source B claims that video games encourage or tolerate violent behavior in the game, probably leading to negative, violent side effects in both children and adults in real life. Source C provides evidence for the opposite, stating that laparoscopic surgeons actually made fewer errors in surgery after playing video games regularly. Source D debunks common video game myths with little-known facts that illuminate some of the negative side effects of violent video games. By comparing the video game producers and consumers with Doctor Frankenstein and Frankenstein’s monster, Source E uses a picture instead of words to illustrate the reality of the video game industry. Source F explores the moral side of the issue, using Grand Theft Auto as an example of how players decide for themselves if they will behave morally or …show more content…

The commentary mentioned that Patrick did not have a unique voice in his writing and he relied on the sources rather than his own reasoning and ideas. He used several statistics in his essay, which provided solid evidence for his argument. Additionally, his ideas were organized well. To improve the essay, some of the informal diction could easily be removed and replaced with academic words. He used first person voice and contractions multiple times, which should also be removed. To improve the essay even more, Patrick could have written a longer conclusion to restate and reemphasize his points for the

Get Access