Pertaining to Tracy Lai’s article titled, “Asian American Women”, Lai discusses how stereotypes dehumanize people while turning them into objects to be manipulated. Lai touches on the topic of how Asian people and cultures are stereotyped as being inferior and exotic. The problem that Lai brings to our attention is that it is a struggle to be an Asian in America due to the fact that Asians have been denied political, economic and social equality in America. Lai also brings to our attention the die hard myth that Asians have made it in America, which is far from the truth.
I sense that Lai’s argument is extremely effective due to the fact that stereotypes are not only seen among Asians, they are also seen in many other cultures and
…show more content…
I have also noticed that there are very few Asian politicians, as well as very few women politicians, within our culture. I do not know if this problem stems from Asian Americans not having a historical/authoritative figure like Dr.
Martin Luther King representing African Americans, and Susan B. Anthony representing woman’s rights to vote. However, I do know that Asians do not receive the same types of opportunities as others because they have been stereotyped for so long as being inferior. In addition, I feel that the reason why
Asians may be seen as inferior individuals is because they were one of the last cultures to start a movement for equality that was inspired by other ethnic cultures.
Because of this somewhat late movement, our culture has not been able to adapt to this change, like our culture has not adapted to women being paid the same as men.
Lai brought to my attention that Asians are claimed to value education more than other minorities and Asians are said to have special intellectual affinities for math and science. Lai proceeded to raise the point that this is a racist rationale because this is implying that other cultures are not able to succeed in this type of area. For instance, I can relate to this statement because African American’s are said to be dominate in athletics, and they are also believed to have a higher vertical leap than others. I was offended when I heard this because I received a scholarship to
The stereotype that Asian Americans just naturally have a step up above the rest that paves the path for the jealousy other ethnicities is really the result of ridiculous amounts of dedication and this group of people should be praised for their work ethic.
“By whom are Asians considered to be the “model minority”? “Is it every race? Is it only other minorities?” Takaki says that African Americans may resent Asians because of this argument. “Did this myth start in the African American community?” Takaki mentions comparisons to the African American community, but does so merely in passing. He needed to elaborate on this notion to really clarify his point. To me, these are all really interesting questions that would have helped Takaki in his quest to dissolve this myth, but he never asks these questions, nor does he answer them. Perhaps these questions and data discovery would be more important and more salient than what he has chosen to present. Perhaps these facts would enlighten everyone to the nature of this “myth” and seek to destroy
The Asian American immigrants are part of the ethnic and racial groups in the United States who lives in the continent of Asia. Asian have lived in the United States for a long time. Throughout the history, Asian Americans have encountered segragation and discrimination during the periods of changes in demographics, economic recession, and war. They have been discriminated by school policies and practices due to beign different. Paul Spickard (2007) has said that Asian Americans was an idea invented in the 1960s to bring together Chinese, Japanese, and Filipino Americans for political purposes. Later, other
There are always times when people stereotype others simply by the way they look at times it is unconscious. It could be thought that one minority group is better than another when in reality all minority groups are the same. “The Harmful Myth of Asian Superiority,” by Ronald Takaki, he claims that the Asian Americans are not as successful as others claim. Even though Takaki gives enough evidence to support his claim, his argument is ineffective because of his undocumented sources, disorganization, and assumptions.
Asian Americans are, as is the widely held belief, the “model minority” for their perceived
The Pew report on Asian Americans is one physical manifestation of the Asian model minority myth- the belief that all Asians are educated, wealthy, assimilable, and submissive. The model minority myth which was actualized during the World War II has since evolved to be more than a stereotype. For many Asian Americans, it has become a tangible barrier, barring disadvantaged Asian Americans equal access to social programs and educational opportunities. The myth has grown to become so influential, so pervasive that it has manifested itself in the discourses on legal policies such as affirmative action and in the rhetoric of the pseudo statistical Pew report. Racism is far from being over; it has taken on new form-praise and laudation- to justify rejection of aid to underprivileged people. The Asian model minority myth has stripped Asian Americans of their diversity and homogenized them as a privileged, educated community. As a result, Asians have
All Asian Americans are good at math, or at least that’s what I heard. They are also good at anything involving technology, science, and medicine. They study all the time, work really hard and live a version of the American dream I never thought to dream of. Afterall they’re Asian, their parents wouldn’t allow for anything less. In his article “The Harmful Myth of Asian Superiority” the ethnic studies expert Ronald Takaki writes about the idea that Asian Americans are more successful than other American minority groups. Takaki refutes this idea using reason and statistics to show that Asian Americans still face some of the same hardships and barriers as every other racially defined group in America.
This is a racial bias toward Asians started with the Yellow Peril stereotype. Followed by the Forever Foreigner stereotype where Asian always seen as a foreigner no matter how hard they reach to white social status. Then continue with the model minority stereotype. In 1960, Peterson wrote an article about the success of Japanese families, “Success story, Japanese-American style.” This was a success story of the Japanese even though they had faced internment by the American government.
The first negative impact is the imposed threat that successful Asians have upon the American society. The ability to thrive and escape their original impoverished background make Asians a strong competitor against White-Americans who are also
Asian Americans face constant subjection to what has become referred to as the “model minority” myth. This myth enforces both a false narrative and broad generalization upon all Asian Americans as the ethnic embodiment of an idealistic work ethic and outstanding academic and socioeconomic success. The deconstruction of this “single story” requires the introduction of new perspectives and proper representation of the intersectional spectrum of Asian Americans, who oftentimes do not fit this typecast. Perpetuating this single story, is the lack of understanding of how Asian Americans can stem from 51 different Asian countries, struggle from the effects of poverty, and also remain unrepresented in popular media.
The population of Asian Americans has gradually increased and it is easy to see Asian Americans on streets in nowadays. However, it is really hard to see Asian Americans in media. Although Asian American people have lived in the United States since 1800s, Asian Americans are often portrayed as perpetual foreigners and they get treated like they do not belong here. In the past, the images of Asian Americans were “aliens” and this affected the media to show negative images of Asian Americans. Asian women often played a female witch in dramas and movies and Asian men played a funny role in dramas and movies. Things got better in nowadays, but the media still shows many stereotypes of Asian Americans.
It is almost impossible to find this kind of headline that replaces “black women” with “Asian women.” Little to no coverage of Asians in the race debate emphasizes the often ignored issues that Asian Americans face everyday, adding to the historical norm being silenced. It may be that Asians are viewed as the most educated/wealthy minority and ostensibly, do not have issues in their communities. Therefore, they’re excluded as a priority in protests and unparalleled to African Americans, Latinos, and Muslims. This places Asians in an awkward middle, where they are neither part of the minority community, yet not at the level of white. Because of this social view of Asians, less issues are addressed and even covered, ignoring the fact that Asian Americans are still vulnerable to political turmoil. The argument of race has become too black and white, and there is minimal contemplation on what it feels like to be an Asian American in today’s society as their history has been periodically buried
When I search “Asian rights in America” on Google, there are almost 68400000 search results. But if I search “Black people rights in America”, there are about 90800000 search results online. It is obviously that there are some differences between these two values and what reason causes this different? Why people focus more attention on black people’s rights not on Asians’ rights? You may say that it’s maybe because the number of Asians is smaller than the number of black people. It’s true. In America, Asians are mineral group and only occupy 5.6 percent of the total American population. But I don’t think quantity is the only influence factor and also I disagree with this assumption that micro community’s rights can be ignored selectively by people. Everyone’s equal and they should have same rights and get same attention from public no matter what skin colors they have and where they come from. It’s year 2016 and in the U.S.A which is a democratic country; I know that black people’s rights matter, white people’s rights matter. But please never forget Asian’s rights matter too.
Finally, even prejudice and discrimination have decreased but many Chinese Americans and Japanese Americans continue to experience these two social issues in the twenty-first century. For example, because many Chinese and Japanese are doing well in mathematics, sometime people may think that all Chinese and Japanese are very good at math. So when they asks Chinese Americans some math questions and they can’t answer those questions, some people might say “I thought you are very good at math because you are a Chinese.” In this situation, many Chinese Americans feel insulted. During the past hundred years, Chinese American had experienced many discrimination action such as Chinese Exclusion Act. Chinese Americans had fought for their right and
America is considered a melting pot of different ethnic groups. By today’s standard, “American culture” is the result of a variety of races integrating their own cultural beliefs into American society. Throughout the years, the United States has seen a massive increase of people migrating from Asian countries; “they make up 3.6 percent of the U.S. population, a 199 percent increase from 1980 when they constituted only 1.5 percent of the population” (Ng). Like other immigrants, Asians come here in order to seek a better life and experience civil liberties. According to statistics, “Filipino Americans today make up the second largest Asian Pacific American (APA) group in the country” (Aquino). Filipinos alongside