preview

Compare And Contrast Winnyott And Winnicott

Decent Essays

Developmental Child Psychology has been defined as a field of study that examines and attempts to explain why and how human beings change and develop over time. Changes include physical change, mental change and social change.
For the purpose of this essay, I will be comparing and contrasting two child development theorists, Donald Winnicott (1896 – 1971) and Eric Erickson (1902 – 1994), and showing how their theories link to therapeutic play.
Winnicott was an English paediatrician and psychoanalyst. He came to prominence in the post Freudian era of the 1930’s. He studied under analyst Melanie Klein. (who followed and developed Sigmund Freud’s school of thought). Klein had an enormous influence on Winnicott’s work, therefore one could say he was influenced by Freud. However, over time, he became more of an independent thinker. He developed many of his own theories and concepts, which were informed by his vast experiences as a paediatrician, which are still widely regarded today.
Erikson was a German psychologist and psychoanalyst. He was a student of Freud, and was greatly influenced by his theories of personality development. Similarly to Winnicott, Erikson drew on his experiences as a child analyst, to inform his contributions. Erikson’s theories, like Winnicott, are highly regarded today.
According to Winnicott, there are three stages in infant development. In stage one, undifferentiated unity, the child must feel connected to the mother. The mother fulfils this need through feeding, bathing and holding the child. In doing so, the child feels all powerful, and incomplete control of the mother. Their every need is met, and they want for nothing. However, Winnicott warns that if a mother fails to respond adequately to the child’s needs, this will hinder the development of healthy future relationships, including the relationship with one self.
In stage two, transition, the child is beginning to individuate from his mother. The child realises it’s dependence, and learns about loss. There is a realisation that other’s sometimes take priority, and their emotions must be considered. Winnicott believes that if this disconnection is done suddenly, it may be traumatic for the child. However, if done well, it

Get Access