preview

Differences Between The Book And The Movie The Natural

Good Essays

With movie culture today, many films are based off books. Harry Potter and Hunger Games are examples of two movie series that closely follow the books on which they are based. However, there are films that drastically stray from their books. The Natural, a baseball movie based on the book, The Natural. Differences in the plot, characters, and theme result in two largely different moods and meanings. Roy Hobbs, the protagonist, has a very altered experience with women in the book than in the movie. In the story, he lusts after Memo Paris, and while he does do so in the movie, the draw to her is not quite as strong. Iris Lemon becomes a much more attractive figure to Roy in the movie, while in the story Roy tries to avoid Iris. The baseball aspects …show more content…

In the book, Roy is involved in accepting a bribe with the Judge and Gus Sands to throw the pennant game. His career crumbles as Max Mercy, a well known sportswriter, publishes information about his past as a prospect and his failure to make it to the big leagues. In one of the final scenes of the novel, Roy confronts the Judge, Gus Sands, and Memo. Roy's regret of his decision is very apparent, but it's too late for him to reverse his downfall. The final line of the book perfectly illustrates Roy's regret: “When Roy looked into the boy’s eyes he wanted to say it wasn’t but couldn’t, and he lifted his hands to his face and wept many bitter tears" (Malamud 449). Roy finally feels the consequences of his actions and acknowledges his error. Since he associated with those who were evil like Memo and the Judge and did not rely on himself and good people like Iris, he doomed himself. The film is a polarizing opposite, however. Roy wins the game by hitting a home run, and his background is never published. He becomes a hero who saved Pop Fisher and the game, and he marries Iris and lives happily ever after. This highlights that if someone has confidence and recognizes what matters in life, that person can truly attain success. Roy utilized the love of his newly discovered son and his newfound love for Iris to boost him to victory. Overall, the endings of the …show more content…

Everybody has his own flaws that sometimes prevent him from attaining a success. Some can resist and overcome their flaws more easily, while others are constantly submitting to their vices. Roy Hobbs is someone who exemplifies both of these traits. In the book, Roy is constantly lusting for bad women and making bad decisions, while in the movie Roy overcomes his lust and associates with those who are good. Roy Hobbs is the perfect example of success, but he is also a perfect example of failure. However, we as individuals need to learn the difference and distinction between the two. We need to take the traits and abilities of Roy in the movie and use them to the fullest extent. But we also need to make a sincere effort to avoid the traits about Roy that cause him to fail in the book. The reason for sin in this world is the failure to see the difference between right and wrong. People have twisted morals that cause harm and destruction, but because of their failure to see and understand the consequences of their actions, they doom themselves to fall to sin. We need to learn from the mistakes of Roy Hobbs in the book, and we need to embrace the actions and decisions of Roy Hobbs in the movie. If one person learns the difference, they can succeed. If we all learn the difference, we can make wiser decisions and have global

Get Access