preview

Gmelch Anthropology

Decent Essays

In 2014, George Gmelch studied and observed the practices, taboos, and fetishes that have been placed by other players perviously in the history of baseball. Gmelch amassed tremendous pieces of information upon us with all these players having different rituals,taboos, snd fetishes . From eating Popeyes every morning to avoiding eating certain foods, whatever flats your boat is what works. By slowly but surely observing all these actions Gmelch put together a piece that really can break down the "baseball magic".

Gmelch used "participation observation" as his method of research. As towards the beginning of his explanation of baseball rituals he gets us with a gabber. When he hits you with the successful ritual, you can already ask yourself, wow does this really work? For these people that are following through with their "baseball magic", you can tell that it becoming more …show more content…

The symbolic anthropology is clearly depicted from even a baseball player hitting exactly four warm up shots every game and making it his current routine. By depicting each ritual, Gmelch really can show the upcoming audience what to expect.

Also by using this I feel as if Gmelch is unable to realize that players can face the problem of maladaptation. Gmelch really didn't touch upon what happens if they don't do their best, or if they do get five warm up shots instead of four. I feel as if the the evidence provided was perfect, but the Magic can be interpreted into having a better meaning because right now it was interpreted into a narrower field of vision that we would have wanted.

This piece can be perfectly compared to cultural relativism because every baseball mans "Routines are conforming"(Gmelch 268). As referred to in the kuru video on youtube they rely on magic for answers, but if you really put it together don't these baseball players as

Get Access