The Gift Of Magi Comparative Essay

It was one week from Della's 30th birthday and Jim didn't have enough money to

Jim and Della perform an act of selfless love by their willingness to give something that held great value to them in order to get special presents for each other on Christmas. They do all of this out of love for the other. However, you will see that these gives prove to end up having no use in the end but that is not the main point. The main point is that although this ironic situation occurs, they both find joy in the thought that they would do this for each other. This love that they have for each other is far greater value than any gift that could be given. Jim doesn’t overreact or get angry with this conclusion.

Both Guy de Maupassant and O.Henry are two very recognized short story writers and they wrote respectively The Necklace and The Gift Of The Magi which are going to be compared in this text. In the Necklace, Mathilde, the protagonist, is a jealous, poor, unhappy person and she does not give values to thing that she has. She is married with a young guy that is poor two but is not jealous. Her biggest fear was becoming poor and it turns reality at the final of the story when she realizes that the necklace was fake. The Gift Of The Magi is a story centered on a young couple living in a small apartment located in New York. They are poor so they have to sell something to buy each other a christmas gift. At the end of the story, the couple realize that they do not need gifts. Both stories deal with young and poor couples who face in a objective and are surprised with a unexpected, ironic turn. The objective of this report is to establish clear differences between the short stories and to provide

The art piece that caught my attention was at the Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art. The piece is called The Adoration of the Magi, painted by Girolamo de Carpi. The Holy Family and the Three Magi’s are illustrated in the painting. They seem to be sitting outside on the ground behind a home made of brick. A sense of space and perception is created because in the distance, behind the people in the painting there is a beautiful view of a mountain and the sun in the sky far from where the people are. In the artwork, de Carpi paints clothes on each person besides baby Christ, and the clothing differ in color; there is red, green, yellow, blue. The colors seemed somewhat bright, in a way indicating that the painting is representing a happy time. Also painted are horses depicted behind a short wall, next to the horses seems to be a servant giving one of the Magis a vessel of some sort.

Similar to “The Cask of Amontillado,” O. Henry includes dramatic irony so the reader becomes emotionally connected to the story and pities its characters throughout “The Gift of the Magi”. It is known that both Jim and Della sold their most prized possessions in order to buy each other a Christmas present. The first instance of dramatic irony is when Della opened her present revealing an exceedingly thoughtful gift from her husband. “White fingers and nimble tore at the string and paper. And then an ecstatic scream of joy; and then, alas! A quick feminine change to hysterical tears and wails, necessitating the immediate employment of all comforting powers of the lord of the flat. For there lay The Combs- the set of combs side and back that

Throughout the story the title "The Necklace" becomes several other symbols, for example when Mathilde loses the necklace and makes the decision to be dishonest, the necklace becomes a symbol of Mathilde's greed and the severe consequences that came with it. After all, the necklace is the reason why Mathilde's life went into extreme poverty and unhappiness.

Seeing the light while in the tunnel is something we all hope for. Likewise, the “modern poets,” or wise men, were longing for the same thing. T.S. Eliot in “The Journey of the Magi,” finds the light at the end of the tunnel. By the use of imagery, symbols, and allusions we will see the Magi, Eliot, find his faith.

According to Bob Marley “ Possessions make you rich? I don’t have that type of richness; my richness is life”.P This quote exemplifies one of the themes of the stories “ The Necklace “ and “ The Gift of The Magi “ which is material possessions. The main character of the story “ The Gift of The Magi “ is Della, who sacrifices herself WW M for her husband. Moreover, the main character of the story “ The Necklace “ is Mathilde, who does not sacrifices herself for his husband. By comparing Mathilde and Della through similarities and differences, it is possible to analyze that, even if they are both women they have different types of behavior and perspectives about how they see life.

The gift of the magi by O. Henry and the sesame street version have many similarities such as how both of the relationships had been extremely close, and how they had sacrificed their belongings so the other could have a marvelous present, even though both had not have that much money at the time. Another similarity that the magi and the video have in common is they would do anything so other would have a outstanding Christmas. While there is many similarities there is also many differences. In the magi, Jim and Dell (main characters) were not able to receive their hair and pocket watch that they had once sold, but in the video they had received their prized possessions that they had once sold.

Similarly, Della and Mathilde both give up the things they need or want the most. In the story “Gift of The Magi” Della cuts her hair and sells it so she is able to buy her Husband a Christmas gift. In the story “Gift of The Magi” the text states “…I had my hair cut off and sold because I couldn’t have lived through

In the beginning of the short story, it is only centered on Della and Jim is mentioned a few times such as, “Only $1.87 to buy a present for Jim. Her Jim. Many a happy hour she had spent planning for something nice for him.” In contrast, the movie has Jim interact with Della at the beginning and shows him buying a gift for Della. This was done to help the audience understand the connection between Jim and Della since it is being translated on screen and overall, expands on their relationship. The movie was more of a show and not

People will do many things to express their love for another person. In "The Gift of the Magi," author O. Henry shows this perfectly through the relationship between Della and Jim and what they're willing to sacrifice for each other’s love.

Although he works hard, he still cannot help to pay the rent. Therefore, he does not have enough money to purchase Della a delightful gift. Eventually, the author reveals that Jim has made the choice to give up one of his most valuable item. What he does, is that he ends up selling his gold watch that was passed down to him from generations. This way he can receive money to purchase Della a heart touching gift. In this situation, Jim speaks, “Dell, …let’s put our Christmas presents away and keep ’em a while. They’re too nice to use just as a present. I sold the watch to get the money to buy your combs. And now suppose you put the chops on’” (Henry 3). This statement demonstrates that Jim has made a similar sacrifice as Della. Similarly, he gave away something so precious and memorable. This supports the theme because he sacrificed his watch, which was a family heirloom. It was very generous of him of selling it to buy something more generic for Della. Him sacrificing his watch represents true love. Some people may say that it was pointless for them to give up their valuable possessions because they didn’t end up being used at all. However, though it’s true that they didn’t end up using their presents, it demonstrates how Della and Jim are brave. This portrays true love and that they are willing to give up or sacrifice things for each other no matter

The Journey of the Magi by TS Elliot centres around one of the three Wise Men who travelled to Bethlehem shortly after his birth bringing him gifts of Gold, Frankincense and Myrrh.