preview

Tom Robinson Trial

Decent Essays

In the novel To Kill A Mockingbird, by Harper Lee, reader's experience prejudice through the eyes of innocence. The protagonist, Scout Finch, is raised by her father, Atticus, who defends Tom Robinson, an African American man accused of raping a white woman. This masterpiece of American Literature has always been controversial as it initiates a conversation about racial injustice and rape. Critics say To Kill A Mockingbird is unfit for a school environment as it uses foul language such as the “n” word and discusses controversial topics that make students uncomfortable. However, there has never been a book written as powerfully as To Kill A Mockingbird that discusses these difficult topics. Despite the controversy surrounding To Kill A Mockingbird, …show more content…

Tom is an honest hard working African American man. Mayella Ewell, an outcast of the community suspected to be a victim of domestic abuse, accuses him of rape. The case goes to trial and through the proceedings, it becomes evident that Tom did not commit the crime. However, despite the state's lack of evidence and the defense's ability to establish reasonable doubt, he was still convicted. The trial mirrors that of the Scottsboro boys. The nine boys were accused of raping two white women. The trial lasted one day, eight of the boys were sentenced to death while the youngest 13-year-old was sentenced to life in prison. Both the verdicts were based on the color of their skin rather than real evidence. Similarly to the Scottsboro boys Dill, one of Scout's close friends, loses his innocence through a trial. After hearing the verdict of Tom’s case, Dill bursts into tears saying, (Quote). Dill knows that what has happened to Tom is not right and is able to empathize with him. Dill’s empathetic outburst gives readers a vivid portrayal of how racial injustice impacts not only the victims but others as well. The author’s memorable narrative of Tom’s trial and of Dill’s reaction to the verdict motivates readers to reflect upon the effects of racial …show more content…

The novel “[Deals] with pathetic loneliness, an accusation of rape, the strangely sexual content of bigotry, a complete failure of justice” (Gerson 2). These are mature topics that can make many uncomfortable. Additionally, teachers say they, “can teach the same lesson with other books,”(Nelson 1). Therefore, they believe if other materials can be used to convey the same learnings without making kids uncomfortable the other materials should be used. However, To Kill A Mockingbird confronts us with our history that can not be changed, and although the novel may make some kids uncomfortable that is not necessarily a bad thing. By being uncomfortable, one is forced to go beyond their comfort zone and forced to think for themselves. If children are shielded from the unfortunate prejudices and inequities of our past, they cannot learn from them, and we are at risk of them being repeated. To Kill A Mockingbird gives insight into American history and the language used during the 1930s, and although this history might make us uncomfortable, it is this uncomfortableness that will help us

Get Access