Layla Cruishank quote “The truth does not always please us and it is not always easy, but there is no compromise for what is right and good” connects to the book Montana 1948 because they both talk about truth and how even when the truth is bad it's better than a lie. Throughout the book there is one secret that David's family that they have lied about and kept quiet for what the book makes out to be many years. The secret is that David's uncle Frank has been sexually assaulting Indian girls since he was very young. When David's father has always seen this as not that big of a deal because of his racist and opinion of Indians and never took any lawful actions. Know David’s father is Sheriff and needs to decide if he's going to do what his father …show more content…
This is the time in this story when David’s father is trying to figure out how he is going to define himself as a sheriff and how far he wants to go against the law just to keep his family happy. His father thinks that it is wrong to lock frank up because he’s his son and Wes’s brother. “Screwing an Indian. Or feeling her up or whatever. You don’t lock up a man for that. You don’t lock up your brother. A respected man. A war hero.” As David’s grandfather always has he looks down on the Indians as less. This connects to Layla Cruishank quote because Wes is deciding whether he want to do the right thing and tell the truth and not lie even though it would be easier and better for his own life. This can also connect to the movie A Time to Kill. The plot of the movie is that two drunk white rednecks raped and tried to kill a young black girl. Then her father killed the two men. The connection I found is during the end of the movie Matthew Mcconaughey has all the jurors to imagine the girl who was raped was white and all of the jurors change their mind and it's a happy ending. The connection is that in both A Time to Kill and Montana 1948 people are saw as less because of their race and people's racist
In the novel Montana 1948, by Larry Watson, we witness this through the eyes of David a 12 year old narrator, the sickness and death of his beloved caretaker Marie Little Soldier by the doing of his Uncle Frank whom he has always looked up to. An important character central to the story is David’s father Wesley the sheriff of Bentrock who is brave, courageous, conflicted and, protective of his family. A message Wesley helps us understand a thought-provoking message that it is difficult to choose between family and doing the right thing.
Both Reginal Rose and Larry Watson shows the importance of achieving justice in their stories. However, what they achieved is different; justice was attained in 12 angry men, while it doesn't in Montana 1948. The prohibiting factors that makes the justice harder to achieved are the prejudice, bias and misuse of power. They also shows the relationship between power and justice, just in contrasting way.
In the Heat of the Night (1967) is a film well defined by the relationship between its two main characters, one of which is black and the other white. The key concept of the film is of the reluctance of the white town (specifically the police force) to accept Virgil Tibbs, a black police officer from Philadelphia, as their equal. The sheriff of the town, Chief Gillespie, is a character who seems to represent society as a whole during the film’s time period (In the Heat of the Night, 1967) . That being said, the character Chief Gillespie is an extremely dynamic character in the film and his essence and outlook changes dramatically throughout the film. The sheriff transforms from a racist, uneducated, close minded individual to one who is more
When he had arrived in Buffalo, Lewis’s first reaction to when they had finally reached his Uncle Otis’s home. “When we reached my Uncle O.C’s home and Dink’s house, I couldn’t believe it, They had white people living next door to them...on BOTH sides.” (Lewis and Aydin March Book 1: 43) Segregation in the north wasn’t a big deal to people in the north than it was in the south and from that he experienced a lot during that visit in the north. Once he had returned back home, he knew what was different now, he understood what the problem and differences were while he was up in Buffalo and at home. It came to him when school time was coming back around in the fall. “ In the fall, I started right the bus to school ,which should’ve been fun. But it was just another sad reminder of how different our lives were from those of white children.” (Lewis and Aydin March Book 1: 47) Between the black and white community, Lewis saw how “degrading” it was when it had came to school. They didn’t have the nice playground, the nicest bus, roads, and the ugly, sad sight of the prison full of black men and only black men, but he had managed to get pass all of the gloominess with a positive outlook of reading. “ I realized how old it was when we finally climbed onto the paved highway, the main road running east from Troy, and passed the white children’s buses..We drove past prison work gangs almost every day the prisoner were always
He was sitting with the most respected Indian in north-eastern Montana, even the whole state, whose name was Ollie Young Bear. David knew that the reason his father was sitting Ollie Young Bear because he was asking Ollie if he had heard anything his brother molesting young Indian girls. David walked over to where his father sat and his father asked him that when he went home that he checked on Marie to make sure she took her medicine.
The hanging before this court scene, on the other hand, proves the philosophies that, while the westerners may not have had quarrels with each other, they had plenty of violent feuds with the Native Indians already inhabiting the lands. In fact, most Civil War Veterans believed the Indians to be “subhuman and racially inferior to whites and therefore deserving of extermination if they could not be controlled by the white population” (Dilorenzo, 2010). The hanging scene simply depicts this hatred blatantly shown towards the Natives. Three men were going to be hanged but only two were allowed to make their final address to the ever-watchful. The two white males had their final words but as the Native man began to speak the hangman silenced him abruptly with a potato sac not allowing him the same respect given to the other men. Amazingly enough, the overall scene of the hanging was rather organized and a good view of the town square was applied to the picture of the West.
Have you faced racial persecution due to the color of your skin? The time was 1900’s and this was the nightmare that Ida B. Wells-Barnett wrote of in Mob Rule in New Orleans. This is the true account of Robert Charles as he fights for his life to escape the hands of a lynching mob. This impassion story collaborates with the witness of this terrifying event that Wells describes. Wells uses her literary skills to shed light on racial discrimination, media bias, and her personal crusade for justice to portray this heart wrenching reality of the violent lynching during the 19th century.
The song “The Death of Emmett Till” by Bob Dylan explains to the audience about a 14-year-old name Emmett Till gets murder by two white men after flirting with a white girl. The lyrics in “The Death of Emmett Till stated, “This song is just a reminder to remind your fellow man. That this kind of thing still lives today in that ghost-robed Ku Klux Klan, but if all of us folks that think alike. If we gave all we could give, we could make this great land of ours a greater place to live.”. The message of this song explains white supremacy still exist today because the white jury stated in the past that the two white men are innocent when the two brothers confess that they killed a black person. This show in the past of American history that the white jury was not fair to the citizen of color or futile against whites. The true meaning behind this song is to explain to the audience that we need to change the ways we make unfair rights against color in order to make America great again. The social justice in this context of the song “The Death of Emmett Till” refer to America needs to
In “The Case Stated” (1895), Ida B. Wells asserts that failure to speak up against racial injustices contributed to the lynch law phenomenon and the loss of many African American lives. Wells supports her claims by giving examples of injustices served to African Americans such as slavery, a constitution that fails to promote equity, and false accusations and lynching’s that resulted in the deaths of thousands of African Americans. In order to convey her passion and desire for change, Ida B. Wells pleads to all Americans, both black and white, to fight for change and stop “avow(ing) anarchy, condon(ing) murder, and defy(ing) the contempt of civilization” (74). Ida B. Wells is not asking for pity for African Americans, she is asking for all
“Mississippi Burning” is based on the investigation of a missing persons case which turned into a murder case in Mississippi that involved three young students who were civil rights workers involved in Freedom Summer of 1964. Two of the students were Jewish and one was an African-American whom came down to Mississippi from New York City. After the students did not return home the parents pushed for media attention since the Mississippi Police were not doing any investigations. The FBI then had to get involved with the case. Little did the parents know that the police were the ones who actually committed the murder of their children. This film shows us the oppression towards African-Americans, specifically in the south.
Revenge is what set the beginning tone of Wexler’s story and the initial reason for why four African-Americans were shot to death. Roger Malcom, one of the lynching victims, stabbed Barnette Hester out of revenge; he believed that his wife, Dorothy, was sleeping with Barnette (Wexler, page13). Since Roger was black and not white, this was considered an act that the white population could not let go unpunished. The death of Roger Malcom was expected by everyone, even Roger knew, “when Barnette Hester died, he would die too” (Wexler, page 55). Many people at the time thought that this was the main motive behind the lynching and that the other three, Dorothy, Mae Murray,
The discriminating social stratification in 1950’s developed a set of servile behavior on the blacks. They were thought to be inferior to whites, and were treated accordingly. Moreover, different parts of the country had various ranges of sensitivities while dealing with the blacks. For example, in Mississippi things were particularly tense after the Parker lynch case. No black man would dare look into any white man’s eyes in fear of the repercussions. On the bus, a man warned Griffin to watch himself closely until he caught onto Mississippi’s ways. In an extreme case like this, it was vital to learn about their roles and behave accordingly.
In the novel, Montana 1948, written by Larry Watson, a story of a young boy named David and the events of a cataclysmic summer holidays are recounted. Set in the heart of North America in the 19th century, when Native Americans were considered B class citizens and persecution was inevitable ever since the Europeans first arrived on the continent. David matures in a short span throughout the text from naivety to maturity as a result of the series of horrendous events he experiences. The murder and sexual assault of Marie Little Soldier evokes a case in which Wes, David’s father and sheriff of the county must re-moralise his choices as his brother Frank is to
Prejudice is a cancer that spreads hate among its perpetrators and victims alike. In 1930 Langston Hughes penned the novel, Not Without Laughter. This powerful story, written from the perspective of an African-American boy named James “Sandy” Rodgers, begins in the early 1900’s in the small town of Stanton, Kansas. Through the eyes of young Sandy, we see the devastating impact of racism on his family and those they are close to. We also see how the generations of abuse by whites caused a divide within the black community. Among, and even within, black families there were several social classes that seemed to hinge on seeking equality through gaining the approval of whites. The class someone belonged to was determined by the color
In A Time To Kill, by John Grisham, two drunken white men violently raped, beat, and nearly killed a 10-year-old black girl named Tonya Hailey. Her father, in a clouded rage, executed the two rapists with an M-16 on their way out of the courthouse. His vigilante form of justice was not well taken by many in prejudiced Ford County, Mississippi. On the other hand, he had lots of support from the black community and from any white person whom dared to step into his shoes. A young, thirty-something lawyer named Jack Brigance was hired as his defense. He personally hoped it would give him national recognition, but his outlook turned sour when an all-white jury was drawn to decide on the fate of this Negro man. As