Eugenics: An outlook into American Genetic Enhancements
Izaaz Kothawala
Abstract
There is a period of time in American History that is usually skipped over when it comes down to the history books. It was the time of selective breeding and genotype selection of humans. During this era, Eugenics was seen as a great potential solution to every defect humans had and to possibly change the future human race permanently. Analyzing it back today, the American Eugenics theories were flawed, corrupting, and morally wrong.
Before analyzing history, the term Eugenics should first be defined. The term “eugenics” was defined by Sir Francis Galton. He quoted, “EUGENICS is the science which deals with all influences that improve the inborn qualities of a race; also with those that develop them to the utmost advantage” (Galton 1904). In a simple form, he meant that Eugenics is a movement
…show more content…
The philosophies can be traced all the way back to Plato who is credited with the initial idea of believing that human reproduction should be controlled and mandated by the state or government. In Plato’s Republic, he stated that mates would be chosen by their “marriage number” which was an identifying number analyzing their qualities as a human. This was theorized to help bare more higher number babies and eventually helping evolve the human race. Aside from Plato, ancient civilizations such as Rome, Athens, and Sparta also believed that newborns would be “tested” by exposing them to harsh environments and that the babies that survived were deemed “fit” to grow and mate in the future. While the ideology had existed for quite some time, Sir Francis Galton was actually the first to coin the term “eugenics” back in 1883. The term “eugenic” roots back to the Greek word “eugenic” which means the improvement of offspring produced. Galton was most influenced by his cousin, Charles Darwin’s The Origin of
Eugenics was introduced by sir Francis galton who, interestingly enough, was a cousin of Charles Darwin. It began as a way to better the human race and stop negative genetic traits from continuing on generation to generation. Eugenics may have started out as a way to better humans but it became something much worse.
The idea of eugenics made it possible for involuntary sterilization. In order to improve the human race, it meant regulating reproduction. 1907 Indiana passed to sterilize the mentally insane and inmates. Their plan was to eliminate “defective” genes. By 1960 63,000 people were involuntary
I support the guidelines outlined by Kitcher for the use of genetic information because of their responsible and ethical nature. I believe that future generations will benefit as a direct consequence of these guidelines. I shall begin by defining eugenics as the study of human genetics to improve inherited characteristics of the human race by the means of controlled selective breeding.
Lack of scientific knowledge about genetic biology was the primary reason why eugenics movement died out towards the latter half of the 20th century. It was concluded that there was actually no significant way to identify “fit” families. The eugenics movement unjustly called people unfit without reason. The primary downside to the eugenics movement in the United States is that scientist paid too much attention to the genetic correlations between class and genes, but rarely looked at the environmental factors that affected the class. Essentially what the eugenics movement did was called families that were alcoholics and thieves due to your genes. An argument could have been very easily made that these families were
It is almost impossible to think that there was a time in American history where eugenics was something that a large mass of the public thought was actually a great idea. But, when it comes time to face reality, one must realize that this was not just a fabled tale of time of the past and that it actually happened. When researching historical events or movements, nothing is more beneficial to find evidence than through popular literature of the specific time period. The novel that sums up what this entire movement is about the best would be Erskine Caldwell’s Tobacco Road.
The eugenics movement began in the 20th century by a man named Francis Galton. As the cousin of Charles Darwin, Galton believed that eugenics was a moral philosophy to improve humanity by encouraging the ablest and healthiest people to have more children (Carlson). This Galtonian ideal of eugenics is often thought of as positive eugenics. Eugenics can be defined as the outgrowth of human heredity aimed at "improving" the quality of the human stock (Allen and Bird). At the other end of the spectrum is what can be classified as negative eugenics and is presently in disrepute. Negative eugenics entails selective breeding in which the least able from the population is taken out of the reproduction pool to preserve humanity's best traits.
Eugenics began in the United States in the 20th century. Sir Francis Galton, cousin of Charles Darwin introduced Eugenics to the world. He first used the word in the late 1800s. The term Eugenics comes from the greek roots for good and origin or good birth (Bouche 1). In America the social movement was led by Charles Davenport in the 1900’s. Eugenics was the social movement where people believed that by selective breeding and sterilization only good traits could be passed down to children. It was believed that by using these methods genetic features would greatly improve. That all undesirable traits would be gone and everyone would be “perfect”. Eugenics was used as a scientific way to get rid of social problems
Just think about a human race free of genetic disease where everyone is intelligent and where society and technology advance at staggering rates. This is the future that is envisioned by those who advocate eugenics. Eugenics is the study of methods to improve the human race by selection of parents based on their inherited characteristics (Hartl). The idea was first discussed by Sir Francis Galton in the 1880’s, but was widely unaccepted by people at first due to fear that it would take away their basic human rights and be misused (Hartl). In the early 20th century, eugenics was a very popular and widespread idea in the United States and there were laws created to encourage certain people to have children, while discouraging others from procreating (Morris 66). The main reason eugenics has fell into such disfavor is because the Nazis cited it as the reason for the Holocaust (Morris 66). The use of eugenics by the Nazis can be compared to the use Islam by ISIS, or the use of Christianity by the Westboro Baptist Church. It is a concept that can be misused based on interpretation and extremism. Eugenics itself is just an idea to improve the human race by selective breeding, not by killing millions. Forms of eugenics should be implemented in society because they eliminate genetic diseases and problems, spread favorable traits and attributes, create a more intelligent and less flawed society, and help advance the human race as a whole.
The idea of eugenics was first introduced by Sir Francis Galton, who believed that the breeding of two wealthy and successful members of society would produce a child superior to that of two members of the lower class. This assumption was based on the idea that genes for success or particular excellence were present in our DNA, which is passed from parent to child. Despite the blatant lack of research, two men, Georges Vacher de Lapouge and Jon Alfred Mjoen, played to the white supremacists' desires and claimed that white genes were inherently superior to other races, and with this base formed the first eugenics society. The American Eugenics Movement attempted to unethically obliterate the rising tide of lower classes by immorally
Eugenics was initially started to prevent and control the reproduction and increase of individuals in the population who were considered to have defective hereditary traits. Forced sterilization
There is much bias and confusion surrounding the topic of eugenics. Many times the reason for this is the lack of understanding of what the term means, where it states “In 1883, Sir Francis Galton, a respected British scholar, and cousin of Charles Darwin, first used the term eugenics, meaning ‘well-born.’ (Genetics Generation, 2015).” This term has evolved to encompass more than just “well-born” as can be seen in the encyclopedia. “The eleventh edition of The Encyclopedia Britannica defines eugenics as ‘the organic betterment of the race through wise application of the laws of heredity.’ (Court, 2004).” The meaning of the word eugenics, due to the way it has been used, confuses many people.
Eugenics is a so-called “science” that claims that certain traits can be selected for by controlling what kind of people are allowed to reproduce and thus lead to an improvement of the human race. Much of eugenics is based the idea that the root causes of many of problems people had such as “poverty, feeble-mindedness-including manic depression, schizophrenia, alcoholism, rebelliousness, criminality, nomadness, prostitution” were all caused by genetics and thus preventing the people who had these traits or illnesses from reproducing would prevent their children from having these illnesses and thus would improve society. (Cheney) Oliver Wendell Holmes summed up the idea of eugenics quite well when he (and all but one justice) ruled that forced
The theory of Eugenics can be dated back all the way to 400 B.C. but was not popularized until the mid-1800s by an English scientist, Francis Galton. He researched and published the theory that aimed to improve the genetic quality of the human population through selective breeding (NC Office of Archives and History). As the half-cousin of Charles Darwin, Galton applied the Darwinism science (survival of the fittest) to heredity characteristics. Two types of Eugenics stemmed from the theory, positive and negative. Positive eugenics is encouraging the “best” people in the society based on financial and personal features to have more children while negative eugenics is picking people with flaws and defects from the population
This interpretation of eugenics paved the way for this “Final Solution.” Following these events, the United States became increasingly concerned over its support of the practice. In 1939, after considerable reflection, the Eugenics Research Organization dropped this practice and stopped using the word in their publication name. (Eugenics-Meanings) Following those events, Eugenics was still studied but very quietly due to the new overall judgment by the people.
The roots of eugenics can be traced back to Britain in the early 1880’s when Sir Francis Galton generated the term from the Greek word for “well-born”. He defined eugenics as the science of improving stock, whether human or animal. According to the American Eugenics Movement, today’s study of eugenics has many similarities to studies done in the early 20th century. Back then, “Eugenics was, quite literally, an effort to breed better human beings – by encouraging the reproduction of people with "good" genes and discouraging those with "bad" genes.” (www.eugenicsarchive.org) According to Merriam-Webster, the modern day definition of eugenics is, a science that deals with the improvement (as by control of human mating) of