preview

Aristotle's Claims Of Utility, Pleasure, And Virtue

Decent Essays

Introduction
In The Nicomachean Ethics, Aristotle claims that there are three types of friendships. The three friendships being that of utility, pleasure, and virtue. First, in Sections 1-3, I will explain Aristotle’s claims of the three types of friendship. After that, in Section 4, I will examine Aristotle’s argument that there are two friendships that are not as lasting as the other friendship. Then, in Section 5, I will analyze whether or not the friendship of virtue can occur between only virtuous people. Next, in Section 6, I will evaluate whether or not true friendship is the friendship of virtue like Aristotle claims. Lastly, in Section 7, I will object to Aristotle’s claims.
1) Aristotle’s First Claim: Friendship of Utility
The first friendship that Aristotle mentions in NE VIII.3. is the friendship of utility. Aristotle’s initial claim about the friendship of utility is that “... those who love each other because of utility do not love each other for themselves but in the virtue of some good which they get from each other (NE VIII.3. 1156a.10-12)”. Here Aristotle is claiming …show more content…

not because of who the person is but in so far as he is useful (NE VII.3. 1156a.13-16)”. This friendship of utility could easily be related to a “friend” you only have at school or in a particular class because they are smart and you two can help each other with school assignments. That would be a modern day example of friendship of utility. “These friendships are only incidental; for it is not as being the man he is that the loved person is loved, but as providing some good (NE VII.3. 1156a. 17-18)”. In this way I can relate it back to the example of the friendship as classmates. It is incidental because the person is providing you with useful knowledge and help with the class that you won’t need later on when you are not taking the class together so you part

Get Access