1) What are the main ideas in each of the two essays? (list 3 for each one)
• Horace Miner’s essay, “Body Ritual Among the Nacirema”, focused on rituals among the people of the “Nacirema” tribe (or the American people). The first main idea of the essay is that all people of this group spend most of their time and earnings on “ritual activity” which targets improving the human body. Leading to the second main idea of the essay which asserts that a fundamental belief among these people is that the human body is “ugly”. The final and overall main idea of the reading is obsession over self-image has caused these people more stress than necessary.
• Lowell and Ellen Holmes’s essay, “The American Culture Configuration”, asserts that one’s culture
…show more content…
The text stated from the beginning that the people of a society are the least aware of the culture. Therefore, the intended audience is probably Americans as it aims to inform the people about the culture. I would say the authors successfully did a good job of informing people of American culture. While the ideas presented were familiar, such as religious freedom and the rise of the technical age, it was nice seeing a further analysis of these …show more content…
Miner’s illustration of the American obsession with self-image and the human body is definitely significant. While “The American Culture Configuration” essay gave good examples and descriptions of several views of American culture, Miner seemed to be focused overall on the topic of self-image. Even unknowingly, most people do take extra time to make themselves presentable due to the fear of being judged. Though I would have liked to probably see more depth on why these people think the human body is “ugly”. Also, maybe include a discussion on what these people consider to be attractive or perfect. Therefore, in decorating the House of Culture I would focus on the cellar and room 1 (objects and people). Specifically, how are our beliefs and values influenced by those we idolize (our celebrities/heroes).
4) Did treating the Nacirema ("American" spelled backwards) as an exotic, foreign group lead you to view the practices described in the essay differently than if the authors had made clear they were writing about 20th century
Effective communication has many aspects that can be described as either transparent or a hidden unknown, which in many readings it describes how ambiguity is a necessary evil in communications. The “Triangle of Linguistic Structure” can give phonology meaning form, semantics the value of meaning, and pragmatics that feature the intention to uncertain communications. The direct statements of saying someone is dead, can be harmful so they use etiquette to give reason to use a buffer and instead say they have moved away. For a literary example I will use “Who am I this time?” by Vonnegut and “Body Ritual among the Nacirema” by Miner, for both readings use ambiguity to hide an allegory of communication concepts. The “Body Ritual among the Nacirema”
In 1956 a professor from the University of Michigan, Horace Miner, wrote an article in The American Anthropologist that has become a mainstay of learning for anthropology students. Miner published the article to show a fictional exotic society called “Body Ritual among the Nacirema” as an example of how one’s own limited perspective might affect the perception of a foreign culture (Miner, 1956, p. 503). The article uses subtle humor to make the reader more comfortable in examining cultural behaviors, physical appearance, and health as the reader soon discovers that the actual society being examined is the American society. To the reader, the article begins to sound very familiar after each paragraph is
Body Ritual Among the Nacirema What is the precise geographical location of this strange tribe, the Nacirema? The Nacirema is a North American group living in the territory between the Canadian Cree, the Yaqui and Tarahumare of Mexico, and the Carib and Arawak of the Antilles. Little is known of their origin, though tradition states that they came from the east.
Furthermore, the Nacirema seek help of the “temple” or “latipso” for other serious illnesses, comprised mainly of medicine men and other female specialists. The culture’s devotion to rituals is undeniable as a considerable sum is required for the service of the “temple,” although “these temple ceremonies may not cure, and may even kill the neophyte, in no way decreases the people’s faith in the medicine men” (173). This belief of the “temple” constitutes checking in to the hospital to treat diseases in the American culture. Often times a significant hospital fee needs to be paid for even a short visit and it is not guaranteed that one would be healed as a result. The American culture’s “ fundamental belief…human body is ugly and its natural tendency is to debility and disease” can help explain the society’s faith in hospitals
Horace Minor applied satire in his article “Body Ritual among the Nacirema.” to the culture of the American people. Several ways in which “Body Ritual among the Nacirema” relate to the core concepts of sociology are through the use of sociological imagination, ethnocentrism and cultural relativism. The American culture is described by Minor in a very unique and humorous way. The author uses satire to examine the rituals that are every day in American culture. The reader thinks at the beginning of the article that they are reading about some uncivilized tribe of people but soon realized that the “rituals” that are being performed are just everyday events that take place in every American household.
In this article, Miner takes the role of an outsider and judges the Nacirema just as we judge other cultures. Miner does an exceptional job of wording things in such a way that we don’t even recognize our own culture. Miner wants us to realize that when someone, such as an anthropologist describes another culture, we can interpret that into being abnormal but in actuality, it is, by all means, very normal.
After reading Horace Miner’s Body Ritual Among the Nacirema I cannot say that I would want to be part of the tribe. A huge reason would be that I could never go from my own Christian faith to the religious practices of the Nacirema. My second reason for not wanting to be part of the tribe is that I could never be subjected to the horrific medical practices and “magical potions” used on every citizen in the tribe.
The term Anthropology refers to the study of mankind as a whole. In the article “Body Ritual among the Nacirema” by Horace Miner, the introduction of a new cultural perspective crosses the boundaries of today’s societal norms. Horace Miner is mainly known for his studies in mankind, and as an anthropologist he must take into consideration, without preconceived opinions the variety of unique cultures within the human race. The Nacirema is a group living in North America whose culture, through the perspective of Horace Miner showcases human behavior taken to its highest degree. There is a common belief among the people of Nacirema in which it is the human body is prone to weakness and disease; therefore, in becoming the focal point of the
Compare the views of these two scholars by answering the following questions. Be sure to find specific examples in the selections to support your answers.
Horace Miner describes the people of the North American tribe the Naciremas as persons “devoted to economic pursuits (Body Ritual Among the Nacirema. Miner. 503.3.2)” and ritual activities of the human body. Miner uses a satirical style, play on words to abnormally describe such cultural upon this tribe. Throughout the text, Miner uses words and or phrases such as: “sadism, masochistic, neophyte, awls, and objects in the exorcism of the evils of the mouth involves almost unbelievable ritual torture of the client.” Horace Miner, uses those such words and phrases to describe the various everyday rituals conducted by the Naciremas by producing ethnocentrism through the readers of his text.
This study examines Horace Miner’s essay “Body Rituals Among the Nacirema. While using the participant observation approach, he gives us a new perspective on the daily behaviors within this group of people. Exploring ethnocentrism and how we view cultures outside of our own.
The author’s purpose in writing this article was not to show the “Nacirema” as an example of how extreme human behavior can become, but how an outside perspective can affect your perception of an alien culture. If one were to look at the “Nacirema’s” cultural behaviors regarding physical appearance and health without any insight or knowledge of the specific beliefs or values of that culture, they might seem bizarre and even incomprehensible. By showing behaviors and “rituals” performed by this unknown tribe, Miner allowed others to see that the way studies were representing distinctive cultures was narrowminded and defective. Without the proper comprehension of the basis of any society, huge cultural misunderstandings could occur. Of
Culture is very fascinating becasue it entails so many elements. Differences in food, talk, dress, religious beliefs and even schooling often determine what region you are from in the U.S. much less then world. The types of rituals that the Nacirema go through are harsh but they still exist as a society. It is hard to understand how they have managed to exist so long under the burdens with which they have imposed upon themselves. (Miner, p507). The fascinating thing about this society is that they have a seemingly possessed fixation with the mouth. It's both admired and despised simutaneously. To them it is the gateway to both lasting or doomed friendship as well as the riddence or existance of physical and mental illness.
1. Which of the three tenets of transcendentalism is the most stressed in the two essays? Use specific details from each essay to support your response.
The second essay, written by Ivory Harlow, speaks of peace and kindness. Today we live in a society that is a little selfish and people are very few who take the time to worry about the welfare of the neighbor. In life everything is returned in one way or another, we never know who we are helping and when we are going to need help. This essay was undoubtedly one of the best I have read, since it invites us to be better people and to keep in mind that kindness gives us peace that many times we do not find and need so