preview

Comparing Chopin's Story Of An Hour 'And One Friday Morning'

Decent Essays

On the surface, the protagonists of Kate Chopin’s “The Story of an Hour” and Langston Hughes’ “One Friday Morning” are quite different individuals. Mrs. Mallard, the fin de siècle protagonist of “The Story of an Hour,” is a young woman who feels unsatisfied and confined in marriage. On the other hand, the protagonist of “One Friday Morning” is a high-school-aged black girl named Nancy Lee who is excelling both academically and socially in the early twentieth century. However, despite these differences, both plots hold an event that is unexpected but welcomed by their protagonist, which is then followed by a second surprise that is devastating. As the two individuals respond to these occurrences, we see common themes of independence, equality, and hope. “The Story of An Hour” and “One Friday Morning” present similar plots with dramatically different …show more content…

Mrs. Mallard, upon discovering that her husband has been killed in a railroad accident immediately retreats to a place of solitude and, whispering, “Free! Body and soul free!” (Chopin 1891, 70). Nancy Lee receives a very different surprise in the announcement that she is to receive a valuable art scholarship. Although each of the protagonists would have called these first surprises good news, they were followed by equally bad news. After relishing her new-found freedom and independence, Mrs. Mallard, upon seeing her husband alive and well, makes the shocking discovery that causes her death, by a thing that the doctors label, “joy that kills” (Chopin 1891, 71). On the Friday morning Nancy Lee was to receive the art award, she discovers that the committee has elected to withhold it from her on the grounds that the presence of a colored student in the art school “might create difficulties” (Hughes 1939,

Get Access