Evaluating Management Control Systems—Ethical Considerations
Magnolia Manufacturing makes wing components for large aircraft. Kevin Choi is the production manager, responsible for manufacturing, and Michelle Michaels is the marketing manager. Both managers are paid a flat salary and are eligible for a bonus. The bonus is equal to 1 percent of their base salary for every 10 percent profit that exceeds a target. The maximum bonus is 5 percent of salary. Kevin’s base salary is $180,000 and Michelle’s is $240,000.
The target profit for this year is $6 million. Kevin has read about a new manufacturing technique that would increase annual profit by 20 percent. He is unsure whether to employ the new technique this year, wait, or not employ it at all. Using the new technique will not affect the target.
Required
- a. Suppose that profit without using the technique this year will be $6 million. By how much will Kevin’s bonus change if he decides to employ the new technique? By how much will Michelle’s bonus change if Kevin decides to employ the new technique?
- b. Suppose that profit without using the technique this year will be $8.5 million. By how much will Kevin’s bonus change if he decides to employ the new technique? By how much will Michelle’s bonus change if Kevin decides to employ the new technique?
- c. Suppose that profit without using the technique this year will be $4.8 million. By how much will Kevin’s bonus change if he decides to employ the new technique? By how much will Michelle’s bonus change if Kevin decides to employ the new technique?
- d. Is it ethical for Kevin to consider the impact of the new technique on his bonus when deciding whether or not to use it? Explain.
- e. Assess the management
control system used at Magnolia Manufacturing and provide recommendations for changes, if any are required. Be sure to discuss: - • Decision authority
- • Performance measures
- • Compensation
a.
Calculate K’s bonus when he decides to employ the new technology.
Answer to Problem 30E
K’s bonus increases by $3,600 and M’s bonus increases by $4,800.
Explanation of Solution
Contingent compensation:
Contingent compensation is the amount paid to the employees on the basis of their performance. Unlike fixed compensation, the contingent compensation is based on the performance of the employee in their respective job profile.
Calculate the change in K’s bonus and M’s bonus when he decides to employ the new technology:
The bonus is given when profit exceeds the target level of $6 million. Hence, initially, the bonus will be zero for K and M as the profit did not exceed the target level of $6 million.
Target profit increases by 20%. The bonus is equal to 1 percent of their base salary for every 10 % profit that exceeds a target. It will be 2%
The increment in K’s bonus:
Thus, K’s bonus increases by $3,600.
The increment in M’s bonus:
Thus, M’s bonus increases by $4,800.
b.
Calculate K’s bonus when he decides to employ the new technology. It is given that the profit for the year is $8.5 million.
Answer to Problem 30E
The bonus has changed by $1,800 for K and by $2,400 for M.
Explanation of Solution
Contingent compensation:
Contingent compensation is the amount paid to the employees on the basis of their performance. Unlike fixed compensation, the contingent compensation is based on the performance of the employee in their respective job profile.
Calculate the change in K’s bonus and M’s bonus when he decides to employ the new technology:
The bonus is given when profit exceeds the target level of $6 million. The current level of profit is $8.5 million.
Change in the bonus of K:
Change in the bonus of M:
Thus, the bonus has changed by $1,800 for K and by $2,400 for M.
Working note 1:
Calculate the bonus on the revised level of profit (10.2 million):
Bonus for K:
Bonus for M:
Working note 2:
Calculate the % of incentive:
Target profit increases by 20%. The bonus is equal to 1 percent of their base salary for every 10 % profit that exceeds a target. It will be 7%
Maximum bonus allowed is 5%. So the bonus will be calculated on the basis of 5% of salary.
Working note 3:
Calculate the change in profit:
Working note 4:
Calculate the bonus on the current level of profit (8.5 million):
Bonus for K:
Bonus for M:
Working note 5:
Calculate the % of incentive:
Target profit increases by 20%. The bonus is equal to 1 percent of their base salary for every 10 % profit that exceeds a target. It will be 4%
c.
Calculate K’s bonus and M’s bonus when he decides to employ the new technology. It is given that the profit for the year is $4.8 million.
Answer to Problem 30E
There will be no change in the bonus as the bonus is zero in both the cases.
Explanation of Solution
Contingent compensation:
Contingent compensation is the amount paid to the employees on the basis of their performance. Unlike fixed compensation, the contingent compensation is based on the performance of the employee in their respective job profile.
Calculate the change in K’s bonus and M’s bonus when he decides to employ the new technology:
The bonus is given when profit exceeds the target level of $6 million. The current level of profit is $4.8 million. There will be no bonus on the current level of profit.
Revised level of profit:
Revised level of profit is $5,760,000. It is below the target level of profit of $6 million. So there will be no incentive for the revised level of profit too.
Thus, there will be no change in the bonus as the bonus is zero in both cases.
d.
Explain whether it is ethical for K to consider the impact of technology change on his incentive.
Answer to Problem 30E
No, it is not ethical for K to consider the impact of technology change on his incentive.
Explanation of Solution
Dysfunction decision making:
Dysfunction decision making is a process where subordinates decide for its benefit without considering the adverse effect of the decision on the business organization.
Considering the impact of technology:
K should not decide employing the technology on a self interest basis. He should consider the importance of the implementation of technology for the benefit of the company. It is ethically wrong to consider self-interest over the organization’s interest.
Thus, it is not ethical for K to consider the impact of technology change on his incentive.
e.
Provide recommendations for changes, if any are required.
Explanation of Solution
Recommendations to Company M:
Following are the recommendations to Company M:
- • K has control over the production of the goods in Company M. He may manipulate the production process for his bonus. So K’s activities should be evaluated on a regular basis.
- • The bonus level is restricted to 5%. It should be increased in order to make the employee more motivated.
- • M’s activity of selling should be evaluated on a regular basis as he may influence the sales to earn some bonus.
Thus, Company M should follow the above-explained recommendations to change the bonus plan.
Want to see more full solutions like this?
Chapter 12 Solutions
COST ACCOUNTING W/CONNECT
- Jace and Associates provides professional consulting services to a variety of clientele in an effort to help them improve the operating effectiveness and profitability of their businesses. At the start of the year, budgeted MOH costs were $250,000; budgeted direct labor hours, its allocation base, were 100,000. The company is considering doing work for a new client that is estimated to take around 45 hours. How much should Jace bid on this job if the company incurs a direct labor rate of $30/hour and charges a 60% mark-up above job costs? (Round answer to 2 decimal places, e.g. 5,275.25.) Bid price $arrow_forwardAt ABC Co., 10% of each salesperson's yearly bonus is based on whether or not the entire company reaches its annual sales goals. ABC's compensation structure is based on the fundamental idea that ______. A) compensation policies must be legal B) incentives will be more effective if it encourages people to act in ways that benefit both society and the person C) people will work to accomplish a goal if they have a real stake in the reaching the goal D) incentive structures should be as simple as possible E) People are more likely to adhere to a policy if they have had some input into the development of the policyarrow_forwardSeal Financial Advisors provides accounting and finance assistance to customers in the retail business. Seal has four professionals on staff and an office with six clerical staff. Total compensation, including benefits, for the professional staff runs about $573,000 per year, and normal billable hours are 8,300 hours per year. The professional staff keep detailed time sheets organized by client number. The total office and administrative costs for the year are $755,000. Seal allocates office and administrative costs to clients monthly, using a predetermined overhead allocation rate based on billable hours. What is the predetermined overhead allocation rate that Seal will use for office and administrative costs? (Round your answer to the nearest cent.) A. $69.04 per hour B. $21.93 per hour C. $160.00 per hour D. $90.96 per hourarrow_forward
- Pinnacle Consulting employs two CPAs, each having a different area of specialization. Judy specializes in tax consulting and Steve specializes in management consulting. Pinnacle expects to incur total overhead costs of $419,400 during the year and applies overhead based on annual salary costs. Judy is a senior partner, her annual salary is $225,000, and she is expected to bill 2,200 hours during the year. Steve is a senior associate, his annual salary is $124,500, and he is expected to bill 1,500 hours during the year. Required: Calculate the predetermined overhead rate. Assuming that the hourly billing rate should be set to cover the total cost of services plus a 25% markup, compute the hourly billing rates for Judy and Steve.arrow_forwardAs the newly appointed Controller of Lynbrook, Inc. you have been asked to evaluate several scenarios that management is considering to improve the overall profitability of the company. Lynbrook manufactures and sells a product called a Wren, its only product. The company normally produces and sells 60,000 Wrens each year at a selling price of $32 per unit. The company's unit costs at this level of activity are included below: Direct materials $10.00 Direct labor 4.50 Variable manufacturing 2.30 overhead Fixed manufacturing overhead 5.00 ($300,000 total) Variable selling expenses 1.20 Fixed selling expenses 3.50 ($210,000 total) Total cost per unit $26.50 The CFO of Lynbrook would like your response to the following three (3) independent situations to present to the management team early next week. Situation #1 Assume that Lynbrook has sufficient capacity to produce 90,000 Wrens each year without any increase in fixed manufacturing overhead costs. The company could increase its unit…arrow_forwardBen Johnson is the manager of the jewelry department of a large chain of department stores. The department store has succeeded on the basis of customer service and quality of merchandise. As a manager, Ben is compensated with a salary of $270,000 and a bonus based on his unit's operating income. The bonus pool is 10% of company-wide operating income. When the unit's return on invested assets exceeds the rate of return of the whole company, the unit manager is included in the bonus pool, which is divided evenly among the managers who qualify for the bonus. In the current period, 25 managers qualified for the bonus, including Ben. Jewelry Department Whole Company $ 45 $ 17,200,000 $ 288,200,000 Stock price Operating income Assets invested $ 1,968,000 $ 23,200,000 Customer service Quality of service Total revenue $ 3,570,000 $ 124,300,000 Required: Based on the above information, what is the amount of total compensation for Ben? $270,000 $341,550 $338,800 $350,800arrow_forward
- A professional division at a business school provides several development programs that have been tailored to the specific training needs of both the public and private sectors. The program director is planning to offer a one-full-day course in risk management to be sold at $2,250 plus orientation fee (5%) per participant. The division incurs a cost of $45,000 for promotion, classroom space, staff and instructor’s salary, as well as a cost of $240 per participant for refreshments, lunch, course material, a gift package, and a framed certificate of completion. How many participants need to register in the course for it to be worthwhile to offer it? Round to two decimal places. Group of answer choices 21.20 26.86 36.72arrow_forwardLisa Claussen, CPA, pays her new staff accountant, Gina, a salary equivalent to $27 per hour while Lisa receives a salary equivalent to $39 per hour. The firm's predetermined indirect cost allocation rate for the year is $16 per hour. Claussen bills for the firm's services at 25% over cost. Assume Lisa works 1 hours and Gina works 16 hours preparing a tax return for Mikayla Jones. 1. What is the total cost of preparing Jones's tax return? 2. How much will Lisa bill Jones for the tax work? 1. What is the total cost of preparing Jones's tax return? Enter the direct and indirect costs for preparing Jones's tax return. Direct Cost: Lisa's time Direct Cost: Gina's time Total Direct Cost: Indirect Cost: Total cost of preparing tax return hrs. hrs. hrs.arrow_forwardB-You is a consulting firm that works with managers to improve their interpersonal skills. Recently, a representative of a high-tech research firm approached B-You's owner with an offer to contract for one year with B-You to improve the interpersonal skills of a newly hired manager. B-You reported the following costs and revenues during the past year (before the proposed contract). B-YOU Annual Income Statement Sales revenue $ 560,000 Costs Labor 260,000 Equipment lease 42,000 Rent 35,000 Supplies 30,000 Officers' salaries 160,000 Other costs 20,000 Total costs $ 547,000 Operating profit (loss) $ 13,000 If B-You decides to take the contract to help the manager, it will hire a full-time consultant at $85,500. The equipment lease will increase by 20 percent. Supplies will increase by an estimated 10 percent and other costs by 15 percent. The existing building has space for the new consultant. No new offices will be necessary for this work.arrow_forward
- Brenda Sheldon, CPA, pays her new staff accountant, Abby , a salary equivalent to $21 per hour while Brenda receives a salary equivalent to $37 per hour. The firm's predetermined indirect cost allocation rate for the year is $11 per hour. Sheldon bills for the firm's services at 34% over cost. Assume Brenda works 6 hours and Abby works 8 hours preparing a tax return for Mikayla Touchstone. 1. What is the total cost of preparing Touchstone's tax return? 2. How much will Brenda bill Touchstone for the tax work?arrow_forwardWV Construction has two divisions: Remodeling and New Home Construction. Each division has an on-site supervisor who is paid a salary of $58,000 annually and one salaried estimator who is paid $52,000 annually. The corporate office has two office administrative assistants who are paid salaries of $38,000 and $31,000 annually. The president's salary is $127,000. How much of these salaries are common fixed expenses? $196,000 $306,000 $110,000 $127,000arrow_forwardSheehan works for Andy Company and is a superior sales guy. His total compensation this year is $600,000. Andy sponsors an integrated profit sharing plan with a base percentage of 5.5% and a maximum excess percentage. It uses the current wage base as the integration level. How much will the company contribute for Sheehan for 2019? Select one: $15,125 $23,491 $23,785 $56,000arrow_forward
- Cornerstones of Cost Management (Cornerstones Ser...AccountingISBN:9781305970663Author:Don R. Hansen, Maryanne M. MowenPublisher:Cengage Learning