There is no active draft set in place in the United States. A group called the Selective Service System administers the draft of the United States. The United States initiated the Selective Training and Service Act of 1940, which made it mandatory for all men, ages 21 through 25 to register for the SSS. The question as to why it is mandatory for men to register for the draft has arisen over the years, and the answer is basically historical. However, times have changed and we live in a world where both men and women are able to serve in the United States military. The acceptance of woman into the U.S military began in the late 20th century, where it was proved that women can serve as effective combat troops. Recently, in today’s news the topic of women registering for the SSS has been brought up. Although I agree with equal …show more content…
Dual military couples were required to have a family care plan set in place in case of one or both parents needed to participate in a field exercise or a deployment. A family care plan was a contract stating an individual as a care provider for the children when the military requires the service members to have to leave for a long period of time. Although many perceive the U.S. military as a family oriented organization, that is certainly not the case. In the military the mission always comes first. Whether it is going on deployment, staying late for work or participating in a field exercise. The mission is always first. If women that voluntarily join the military to serve their country struggle to find reliable people to care for their children while being deploy, making it mandatory for women to register for the SSS would be a nightmare. Women are gifted with carrying and giving birth to a human being which forms such a great bond, requiring women to give the right up of raising their children is
For years women have been trying to gain gender equality throughout the working world, along with in the military. Since the beginning of a uniformed military, women could not serve in military occupational specialty (MOS) positions that put them in direct combat roles. Although many women have contributed in significant ways, they have not been authorized to serve in MOS such as infantry, artillery, or armor. As the war on terrorism has developed since 9/11, women have slowly worked their way farther into the military and its many roles. This resulted in women being placed into direct combat roles. Though women have been allowed into many different roles, there is still one battle that they have yet to win and this time the majority is not backing them. Women are trying to gain access to United States Special Operations units in every branch of the military and the majority of these operators are not happy about it. While some people believe women deserve equality and the chance to do what men can do in the military, that is why women should not be
In the tragic case that the United States does have to call for another draft at least they’ll have the numbers they need to support the military. If the United States is willing to call a draft it is apparent that they need help. According to Scott Dunn, an army lawyer “Congressional opposition to drafting women centered on the exclusion of women from combat roles” (Dunn 8). In January 2016 women were granted the right to choose any military job including combat roles. Now that women can participate in combat there is no excuse for them not to be required to register for the draft. It is now legal for women to hold all the same positons as men so, what makes them less when it comes to being drafted? With the help of women, the military will be able to cover more ground than ever before. Instead of only using the women as nurses which takes more training than combat, the military can now train women to become fit for combat if necessary. Women will not only contribute to the numbers, but to the leadership needed in front line roles. According to Harvard Business Review, a journal written by professors and students at Harvard Law School, “More women were rated by their peers, their bosses, their direct reports, and their other associates as better overall leaders than their male counterparts — and the higher the level, the wider that gap grows” (Women’s Bureau 1). This is important because it proves that women can be a vital contribution to combat roles. Not only can they participate in the battles, but they can help lead them also. The more women military leaders there are in the military the more diverse the military will
In conclusion I feel that women should not be mandatory drafted in the military not because they aren’t necessarily good enough just that there is major issues to why they shouldn’t. They want to have a baby, cannot really achieve to what is required (in that means by being able to carry a heavy man or equipment), might not be emotionally prepared for what will happen in they end up in war, and also might not be prepared to be yelled at (emotions). In that case women should not be drafted in the military they honestly won’t be able to handle
Another thing that should prevent women to be in the draft is emotion. Women are complex beings with many chemical emotions causing them to react differently than men. Women’s brains perceive things in a more maternal way there for they consider circumstances differently. If a situation was complicated and needed an immediate reaction a woman might not be the right person to make an instant and thought out decision. She might reflect on it in a way that didn’t conjure what the troop needed at the moment. Women that are forced to be in war can easily get overwhelmed. Men can come through due to instinct after hundreds of years of being the ones who take care of the physical and difficult tasks at hand but women might not be as likely to react logically and can be easily inundated by the stress. Having maternal instinct rather than survival technique can be a vast disadvantage in combat causing emotion to be a handicap.
Only men are required to actually sign up for the draft after turning 18 years old.
Today if there were a draft it would be completely different from the way they have done it for the Vietnam War. Men could have lower reasons to not go into the draft congress tried to make some changes to the act in 1971 so that young men could qualify for deferment.” Under the draft law can have his induction postponed only until his current semester is over”(Smith). The lottery would still help determine what the call line will be, but before that the local board called classified men as 1-A from ages 18 to
As the US military opens combat roles to women, several politicians ask that registration for the draft be required for women, eliciting the support of some young Americans.
Should women be allowed in all areas in the military? Making a draft for women will destroy families, cost more money for the military, and women have a big disadvantage against men. If there is a draft for women it will only make things harder on everyone. If women want to serve, go find another job; and there is no reason why they should be forced to. Because of these reasons there should not be a draft for women.
Women in the Draft In the year of 1917, President Woodrow Wilson founded the United States Selective Service System. The federal government adopted the system to help build an army for America to enter World War I. All men between the ages of 18 and 25 are required by law to register for the draft within the first 30 days of their 18th birthday otherwise they will be penalized. Sociology expert, Geva, explains that although men were required to register for the draft there were some expectations: “Men with economic dependents, including a wife and or/children, would be deferred from the draft.
Forms of conscription have existed since the Civil War but was not run by the Selective Service Agency until the twentieth century during the Vietnam and World War II. Much like every aspect of American society, the draft was voluminous with inequalities and injustices. Women, for one, were and still are not required to required to register with the Selective Service to be drafted despite having access to all combat roles and demonstrating to our nation that they, like men, can perform in these roles. Women have every right to fight for equality and have access to all of the jobs men do but with power comes responsibility and it should be of no surprise that many believe that every American who is physically qualified should register for the draft, including women.
Stated in Article 12 of the National Assembly’s own Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen, “The security of the rights of man and of the citizen requires public military forces. These forces are, therefore, established for the good of all and not for the personal advantage of those to whom they shall be intrusted.”1 This is what the draft stated before the amendment stating women and men are equal! The forces are here for the protection of all citizens. No place in this article, or in any of the other articles, is there a statement saying women are not allowed in the National Guard. Article 12 only says that the public deserves to have a military force for their protection. There is no description on who is eligible to be in this public military, for the fact that there is no reason to have a description. Any, and all, persons that wish to join the National Guard may do so for their own just reasons. Whether that reason be to protect their family, land, or neighbor, it is still a reason to join the National
In the article “Women in the Military” mentions the women have been joining the military since 2000. Besides that, women who serve the military do require a lot of physical requirement because of stereotypical thinking of women being weak. Even more, some commanders want more women to participate in the use of technology. Women tried fighting this kind of idea but managed to fail; In 2003 young women named Lynch was the only survivor of an insurgent attack in Iraq, which motivated more women to join the army. Even more, women that join the army also experienced harassment and rape. After these incidents, it was decided that the military training was not going to be co-ed basic training. By doing this the pentagon announced in 2013 that they
No matter your race, gender, or any other of your characteristics of yourself should not matter when someone is making a decision about you. So women should be treated just as men are when in the military. Decisions should be based off of facts and data about them, not their gender. Men and women have walked side by side ever since they have been on planet Earth, so why are men seen as superior or held at a higher standard? Some reasons why we have to enforce gender equality in the military are the following sentences. Women are a part of the military. Serving in the military is not about gender, it is if you meet all the standards. And they tension between men and women doesn’t rise.
In Women in the Military, Janette Mance explores the debates and problems faced by the increasing number of women involved in the military. After examining issues such as pregnancy, sexual harassment, and rape, Mance concludes that as a society we must continue to strive for gender equality.
Women have fought alongside men in the United States Military in every major battle since the American Revolution. The roles of women in the military have evolved over time to allow the incorporation of women in expanding military career fields. Women have proven themselves to be an asset to the military despite some of society believing women would weaken America’s military effectiveness. Today more than 200,000 women are active-duty military, this is about 14.5% of all military. Currently, women are involved in all branches of the Armed Forces; there are around 74,000 women in the Army, 62,000 in the Air Force, 53,000 in the Navy, and 14,000 in the Marine Corps (By the numbers: Women in the U.S. Military). Military women continue to