preview

Civil Libertary Analysis

Decent Essays

Another point to discuss is the matter of civil liberties within the two nations. From a western standpoint it is assumed at the application of Islamic law results in an overtly conservative situation, but after discussing the legislation and the judiciary systems it is observed that there is considerable leeway in how Qatar and the UAE function. One aspect is that both men and women are allowed to serve in the military, where Qatar is currently discussing the idea of creating more participatory roles for women in the medical, cultural and social fields of the military. One of the advocates for gender equality and Qatari UN representative, Alya Ahmed Saif Al Thani, discussed the current inequality of roles where because of the culture, it is …show more content…

Like the press, Qatar allows the freedom of assembly and association, but restricts its practice. One example is that despite having a national workers union, the legal parameters prohibit the membership of non-citizens and government sector employees. In a country like Canada who has a strong local work force and wants to focus on employing its own citizens, this rule would be acceptable. But over 90 percent of the labour force in Qatar is from migrant and expatriate workers. Once again, the legislation dictates an ethical stance, but it is the ones in power who refuse to apply it in the manner in which it was intended. The UAE differs in this aspect since the only way large meetings can be held is with a government permit. From a civil rights standpoint, this appears oppressive, but there may be a security reason for it as well. By having a large group of people assembling, many possibilities can happen, therefore by having prior information about the gathering, the government and police force would have the ability to prevent possible conflicts depending on the nature of the assembly. Therefore, although there are strict rules in place, the UAE does not remove the rights of the people like the Qatari Government …show more content…

However, due to the greater outside relationship the UAE has with foreign investors and tourists, it has developed a more liberal attitude within its legislations and allowances than Qatar. This has been demonstrated through the government structures, where despite allowing democracy, Qatar does not let it happen on a regular basis for weak reasons, which defeats the purpose of practicing democracy in the first place. At the same time, the UAE only allows a fraction of the population to vote, but the way the government is run has benefitted the nation, therefore there is no immediate motivation to dispute or rectify it. At the same time, the Qatari laws remain very conservative in a modern world, whereas the UAE has adapted its laws and judiciary system to conform to its tourist and foreign industries. Since tourism does have a large impact on the country’s financial income, the recognition of international customs is very important, especially in the business hubs of Dubai and Ras al Khaimah. The applications of civil liberties is also of concern in Qatar and the UAE, but it should be remembered that the UAE does not theoretically take away these liberties like Qatar does by contradicting its own constitution by having the ruling family influence the media, then disallow the vast majority of its labour

Get Access